Start with the supplied information
We separate the case facts from existing interpretations. A report's conclusion is part of the history, but the actual method and result remain the observations to examine. Dates, specimen types, units, controls and treatment timing can all change meaning.
Check the inference one step at a time
| Check | Question |
|---|---|
| Fidelity | Does the explanation preserve the supplied observations? |
| Synthesis | Does the leading explanation account for the important pattern? |
| Experimental scope | What does each controlled comparison identify? |
| Reference support | Does the cited source support the particular claim? |
| Alternatives | Which material alternative remains, and what weighs against it? |
| Consequences | Does the proposed next step follow from the evidence? |
| Teaching | Does the explanation make the mechanism understandable? |
The framework is an editorial aid. It is not a validated diagnostic score, certification standard or clinical-outcome measure.
Describe a limitation precisely
An explanation should identify the missing link: for example, whether a molecular finding has been assigned to a cell population or whether a measured signal demonstrates a particular biological function. That is more useful than simply saying the case is uncertain.
Match claims to evidence
We check whether a source describes the same test, disease, population and outcome as the sentence it supports. We distinguish a biological hypothesis from an established clinical benefit. The reference-checking guide demonstrates this process.
Treat examples and validation differently
The public case notebooks are curated synthetic teaching examples. Some underlying cases were used during product development. They are not a blinded, prospectively selected head-to-head trial. They cannot establish how often a tool will be correct in routine care.
Published comparisons should report the selection of cases, configurations, dates, rater expertise and scoring method. Cases used to improve instructions should be separated from an unseen evaluation set. Relevant reporting frameworks include DECIDE-AI for early live clinical evaluations and TRIPOD+AI for prediction-model studies; their scopes should not be conflated. [1] [2]
Keep evidence of clinical benefit separate
A better written explanation is a useful result in an answer comparison. It is not itself evidence of improved patient outcomes. Evidence about clinical benefit requires an appropriate study of the tool in use.
This distinction allows strong, specific claims about an observed answer without expanding them into claims the test did not measure. Read the guide to comparing medical AI or inspect the retained answer comparisons.